A neglected apartment and the betterment tax exemption: physical condition on the day of sale, planning designation and the cost of renovation

14 November 2026 · Real estate taxation

A neglected apartment and the betterment tax exemption: physical condition on the day of sale, planning designation and the cost of renovation

The betterment tax exemptions on the sale of an apartment and the beneficial linear calculation apply only to a residential apartment as defined in the Real Estate Taxation Law. An apartment in a residential building, with a residential building permit, may fall outside the definition if on the day of sale it has no usable kitchen, bathroom, electricity or water.

The definition in section 1 of the Law

The Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963 (the “Law”) defines a residential apartment in section 1 as an apartment or part of an apartment whose construction has been completed, which is owned or leased by an individual, and which is used for residence or intended for residence by its nature, other than an apartment that is business inventory for income tax purposes. The definition contains four cumulative conditions: construction has been completed, the right is held by an individual, the apartment is used for residence or intended for it by its nature, and it is not business inventory. An apartment that fails any one of them is not a residential apartment, even if the other three are met.

The term “apartment” is not defined in the Law. The courts draw on section 52 of the Land Law, 1969, under which an apartment is a room or unit, or a set of rooms or units, intended to serve as a complete and separate unit for residence, business or any other purpose. The third condition has two alternatives: the apartment is used for residence in practice, or it is intended for residence by its nature. An apartment that has stood empty for a long time can meet only the second alternative.

The relief that depends on the definition

The exemptions in section 49B of the Law apply to the sale of a “qualifying residential apartment”. Section 49 defines it as a residential apartment used mainly for residence for four fifths of the period for which the gain is calculated, or for the four years before the sale, and provides that a period in which the apartment was not used at all counts as a period of residential use. An apartment that stood empty for years can therefore be a qualifying residential apartment, provided it first meets the basic definition in section 1, including the condition that it is intended for residence by its nature.

Section 48A(b2) of the Law sets the beneficial linear calculation. On the sale of a qualifying residential apartment bought before 1 January 2014, the real gain accrued up to that date is exempt, and the rest of the real gain is taxed at the rate in section 48A(b)(1), 25%. The beneficial linear calculation also requires the property to be a residential apartment.

The definition also affects the buyer. Purchase tax on a right in real estate that is not a residential apartment is 6% of the sale value under regulation 2(1) of the Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) (Purchase Tax) Regulations, 1974, and a residential apartment is taxed in brackets that depend on the type of buyer and the number of apartments the buyer owns. The Real Estate Taxation Director classifies the same property in both assessments, the seller’s and the buyer’s, and the classification affects both.

The relevant date is the day of sale

The conditions of the definition are tested on the day of sale. In Civil Appeal 2170/03 Shechner v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 59(2) 250 (2004) (“Shechner”) the Supreme Court held that the relevant date for the conditions is the date of the tax event, the date of sale of the right in real estate, because the exemption crystallises when the tax event occurs. The condition of the apartment years before the sale, and a renovation the buyer carried out afterwards, are at most evidence of its condition on the day of sale.

A shell apartment

A shell apartment is an apartment in a completed building whose interior works were not carried out: it has no sanitary fittings and taps, flooring, internal doors and the like. In Civil Appeal 6107/20 Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv v. Ma’ayan (19 July 2022) (“Ma’ayan”) a couple held a shell apartment on the 16th floor of a building at 1 Rothschild Boulevard in Tel Aviv. They completed a renovation on 23 December 2013 and on 25 December 2013 signed an agreement to sell it for NIS 45 million. The buyer regarded it as a shell apartment, took no interest in the nature or extent of the renovation, and began removing it shortly after the purchase. The Director argued that the renovation was carried out only to obtain a betterment tax exemption before Amendment 76 to the Law took effect at the beginning of 2014. The Supreme Court dismissed the Director’s appeal by a majority, held that the apartment would be taxed as a residential apartment, and regarded the renovation as legitimate tax planning, even though it had no commercial rationale. The appeals committee that heard the case (Appeal (Tel Aviv) 28079-10-15 Ma’ayan v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (19 July 2020)) held that a property in a residential building, connected to the electricity and water networks, may be a residential apartment even when facilities are missing, if they can easily be installed.

For purchase tax the definition of a residential apartment is different, and includes an apartment whose construction has not been completed. The decisions on shell apartments, missing finishing works and buildings under construction are collected in the article Purchase tax on an apartment whose construction is not finished.

The objective physical test

In Civil Appeal 668/82 Koresh v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 39(2) 385 (1985) the Supreme Court held that the words “by its nature” show that the legislature chose an objective test, and that the owner’s intention does not decide the matter. The apartment is examined as it is, to see whether it can in practice be used for residence in terms of its structure and of the facilities essential to ordinary and reasonable use by occupants, such as electricity and water, toilets and a kitchen. Under the same judgment, an apartment used as an office that still has a kitchen, toilets and electricity and water does not change its nature even when the owner does not intend it for residence. Its nature changes when its structure changes, for example when the toilets or the kitchen are demolished.

In Civil Appeal 178/87 Batat v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 43(1) 743 (1989) the property was examined from the point of view of a reasonable person: would a reasonable person choose the property to live in. Under this formulation too, the question is whether the property has the basic facilities for residence, such as a kitchen, a shower, toilets, and water and electricity supply.

The supporting tests from Shechner

In Shechner the Supreme Court held that the real potential for residence is examined in each case according to all its circumstances, including the nature of the property and its internal facilities, the building plans, its surroundings, when it was built and how it was actually used. A property built a hundred years ago is not measured by the same standards as a property just built. Later case law held that the presence of all the physical facilities does not require a finding that the property is a residential apartment, and that the absence of some of them does not necessarily rule it out (Civil Appeal 1046/12 Hakim v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (21 January 2014); Appeal 4036-03-14 Lin v. Betterment Tax Director, Tel Aviv (8 March 2016)).

Planning designation and the reason for neglect

The planning designation of the property, under the outline plan and the building permit, is weighed among the circumstances, and the courts treat it as a starting point (Civil Appeal 237/87 Golan v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 44(3) 348 (1990)). Two decisions of the Haifa appeals committee gave it different weight. In Appeal 20028-12-14 Mano v. Real Estate Taxation Director (11 June 2018) (“Mano”) the planning designation was given decisive weight, and the committee also considered whether the property had deteriorated against the owner’s will. In Appeal 1701-07-24 Schwartz v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Haifa (17 August 2026) (“Schwartz”, also cited as Yaakobi, after the deceased owner) the committee rejected both findings. The table sets out the two approaches as Schwartz describes them.

Issue Mano (2018) Schwartz (2026)
Weight of the planning designation Decisive One factor among several. Where the property is neglected and ruined on the day of sale, the physical test prevails
The reason the property deteriorated Considered whether it deteriorated against the owner’s will The reason and who is responsible are irrelevant

According to Schwartz, if the planning designation always decided the matter, the physical test would be emptied of content. Examining the reason for deterioration requires an inquiry into the owner’s intentions and motives, which the Director cannot carry out simply and clearly, particularly where the owner died many years ago and there is no information on the use and condition of the property before the death.

The apartments on Nordau Street and Weizmann Street in Haifa

In Schwartz an estate administrator sold two apartments in Haifa, at 28 Nordau Street and 5 Chaim Weizmann Street, owned by a woman who died on 17 September 1990. The apartments had stood empty for more than thirty years. Both are in buildings built in the 1930s, in an area zoned for housing, with residential building permits. The administrator claimed the beneficial linear calculation and the Director refused. The committee held that the apartments were not owned by an individual, because the will dedicated them to a public purpose and created a public endowment. Beyond what was necessary, it also examined whether the apartments were intended for residence by their nature.

The committee learned the condition of the apartments from two appraisals for each: one from 2006, and one from January 2022 commissioned by the administrator before the sale. A fire broke out in the Weizmann Street apartment some years before the sale. The 2022 appraisal described a sooty apartment, walls and ceiling without plaster or paint, exposed reinforcing steel in the ceiling, electrical conduits without sockets or switches, no lighting, and old wooden windows with broken panes, and stated that the electrical and plumbing systems had to be rebuilt and a kitchen and bathroom installed. No kitchen or bathroom could be made out in the attached photographs.

The Nordau Street apartment was in better condition. The 2006 appraisal described pigeons, droppings and feathers throughout, damp, a peeling ceiling with exposed steel and a ruined kitchen, and the 2022 appraisal described ruined kitchen cabinets that needed replacing, a worn bathroom and missing doors in some rooms. The administrator argued that at least the Nordau Street apartment was a residential apartment. The committee held that each property is examined on its own, according to its physical condition on the day of sale, and that the comparison between the two apartments was irrelevant. A kitchen that cannot be used on the day of sale is not a kitchen for the purposes of the test, and the appraisals included no photograph of the bathroom. Both appraisals stated that this apartment too was not fit for residence and needed a full renovation.

The committee added three facts to its considerations: the apartments had not been used for residence for decades; the will intended them for week-long holidays, as a kind of guest house, and not for residence; and the Haifa municipality exempted them from municipal tax as ruined and empty properties. The committee held that neither apartment was intended for residence by its nature on the day of sale.

Whether renovation pays

The administrator argued, relying on the appraisal he commissioned, that investing in renovation was worthwhile and that every amount invested would raise the value of the apartment accordingly. Schwartz held that whether renovation pays is a relative test: the relation between the value of the property before renovation, the cost of renovation, the value afterwards, and the rent that can be obtained afterwards. Under the 2006 appraisals, the Weizmann Street apartment was worth about USD 36,000 as it stood and the renovation would cost about USD 18,000 plus VAT, and the Nordau Street apartment was worth about USD 40,000 and the renovation would cost about USD 18,000 plus VAT. The renovation cost was about half the value of each apartment.

The 2022 appraisals estimated the renovation at NIS 56,000 for the Weizmann Street apartment and NIS 33,000 for the Nordau Street apartment, based on 1992 renovation costs indexed to 2021. The committee found these estimates unreasonable: they were lower than the 2006 estimate, about NIS 81,000 at an average rate of about NIS 4.5 to the dollar, even though they were made fifteen years later and after the fire. The appraisals did not address whether renovation would pay, no data on rent after renovation were presented, and no evidence was brought of the cost of the renovation the buyers carried out. The committee found no basis for holding that renovation would pay, and doubted that the test carries significant weight in deciding whether a property is a residential apartment.

The seller’s statements to other authorities

On 14 February 2021, after repeated requests by the administrator, the Haifa municipality granted both apartments an exemption from municipal tax under section 330(1) of the Municipalities Ordinance [New Version], an exemption for a ruined or damaged property that is not fit for use. In an application for directions to the Family Court the administrator wrote that the Nordau Street apartment was not fit for residence, that the Weizmann Street apartment could not be entered, and that preparing the apartments for holidays would require very large sums.

The Director argued that the administrator was estopped from claiming otherwise to obtain a tax benefit. The committee held that a decision of another authority under another law, with a different purpose, does not change the nature or designation of the property, and that the seller’s statements that the apartments were not fit for residence and that preparing them did not pay could nevertheless not be ignored.

Consistency between the seller’s and the buyer’s assessments

In the buyers’ purchase tax assessments the apartments were classified as residential apartments. The administrator asked to rely on those assessments and argued that one rule cannot apply to the seller and another to the buyer. On 16 January 2025 the Director gave notice that the classification in the buyers’ assessments was made in error and that proceedings had begun to correct them. The committee held that the assessment of the seller and the assessment of the buyer must be consistent on whether the property is a residential apartment, and that the Director may not make contradictory findings. Since the Director corrected the buyers’ assessments, the seller could not rely on the error. In Appeal 15365-08-24 Tousia-Cohen v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (15 September 2026) (“Tousia-Cohen”) the sellers’ report of a sale of a qualifying residential apartment served as evidence against the buyers, who claimed they had bought a shell apartment.

The finding also affected the calculation. In the best judgment assessment the Director deducted depreciation, and deducting depreciation reduces the balance of the acquisition value and increases the gain. The committee ordered the depreciation deduction cancelled, since the apartments were held not to be residential apartments.

Burden of proof

In tax proceedings the burden of proof lies on the taxpayer, particularly when claiming an exemption or relief, as the party seeking to take from the other (Civil Appeal 852/86 Assessing Officer, Jerusalem v. M.L.L. Haifa Electronic Data Processing Ltd., PD 43(1) 670 (1989); Civil Appeal 6486/02 Lahav v. Betterment Tax Director (9 October 2005)). A seller claiming an exemption or the beneficial linear calculation must prove that the property is a residential apartment.

In Schwartz the parties waived evidence, and the case was decided on the pleadings, their attachments and the closing submissions. No evidence was presented of the use of the apartments before the owner’s death in 1990, nor any information on whether they had ever been let for residence or another purpose, and the committee held that the burden had not been discharged. The argument that the apartments were neglected because of failures of a previous administrator was not proved either: it was not shown when he was appointed, or what options for action and funding he had.

A new ground raised at the objection stage

Section 87 of the Law allows the Director to reconsider an assessment at the objection stage, and section 87A provides that the person who made the assessment will not decide the objection to it. According to Schwartz, the official deciding the objection may reject the self-assessment on grounds other than or in addition to those in the best judgment assessment, provided the taxpayer was given a reasonable opportunity to present arguments, as section 87(g) requires.

The best judgment assessment did not state that the apartments were not residential apartments. The point was first raised at the objection hearing on 12 May 2024, after the administrator submitted the appraisals on the condition of the apartments. The administrator responded orally and filed supplementary written submissions, and the committee rejected his argument that this was an impermissible expansion of the dispute.

In Tousia-Cohen the committee held that an objection hearing, like the first stage, must take place face to face, and that a telephone conversation is not a proper assessment hearing. The defect did not change the outcome in that case, because the appellant confirmed that he had not been prevented from submitting any document or evidence, and the committee noted, referring to Appeal (Central) 45230-06-22 Salem v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (13 July 2026), that continuing the practice may lead to the assessment proceedings being set aside.

Further reading

Sources

Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 1963, sections 1, 9, 48A, 49, 49B, 87 and 87A · Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) (Purchase Tax) Regulations, 1974, regulation 2(1) · Land Law, 1969, section 52 · Municipalities Ordinance [New Version], section 330 · Civil Appeal 668/82 Koresh v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 39(2) 385 (1985) · Civil Appeal 178/87 Batat v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 43(1) 743 (1989) · Civil Appeal 237/87 Golan v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 44(3) 348 (1990) · Civil Appeal 2170/03 Shechner v. Betterment Tax Director, PD 59(2) 250 (2004) · Civil Appeal 1046/12 Hakim v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (21 January 2014) · Civil Appeal 6107/20 Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv v. Ma’ayan (19 July 2022) · Appeal 4036-03-14 Lin v. Betterment Tax Director, Tel Aviv (8 March 2016) · Appeal 20028-12-14 Mano v. Real Estate Taxation Director (11 June 2018) · Appeal (Tel Aviv) 28079-10-15 Ma’ayan v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Tel Aviv (19 July 2020) · Appeal (Central) 45230-06-22 Salem v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (13 July 2026) · Appeal 1701-07-24 Schwartz v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Haifa (17 August 2026) · Appeal 15365-08-24 Tousia-Cohen v. Real Estate Taxation Director, Netanya (15 September 2026)

General overview only, not legal advice. Tax law and case law are updated from time to time. Updated 14 November 2026.

x
סייען נגישות
הגדלת גופן
הקטנת גופן
גופן קריא
גווני אפור
גווני מונוכרום
איפוס צבעים
הקטנת תצוגה
הגדלת תצוגה
איפוס תצוגה

אתר מונגש

אנו רואים חשיבות עליונה בהנגשת אתר האינטרנט שלנו לאנשים עם מוגבלויות, וכך לאפשר לכלל האוכלוסיה להשתמש באתרנו בקלות ובנוחות. באתר זה בוצעו מגוון פעולות להנגשת האתר, הכוללות בין השאר התקנת רכיב נגישות ייעודי.

סייגי נגישות

למרות מאמצנו להנגיש את כלל הדפים באתר באופן מלא, יתכן ויתגלו חלקים באתר שאינם נגישים. במידה ואינם מסוגלים לגלוש באתר באופן אופטימלי, אנה צרו איתנו קשר

רכיב נגישות

באתר זה הותקן רכיב נגישות מתקדם, מבית all internet - בניית אתרים.רכיב זה מסייע בהנגשת האתר עבור אנשים בעלי מוגבלויות.