Cancelling a property sale in Israel: when the Tax Authority refunds betterment tax and purchase tax

20 November 2026 · Israeli real estate tax

Cancelling a property sale in Israel: when the Tax Authority refunds betterment tax and purchase tax

When a sale of Israeli real estate is cancelled and the Tax Authority does not recognise the cancellation, the tax paid on the sale is not refunded, and the return of the property to the seller is treated as a second sale that carries its own tax: betterment tax for the buyer, who sells the property back, and purchase tax for the seller, who buys it again. The Tax Authority recognises a cancellation where it is shown that the sale had no real effect in practice. In deciding this it looks at the time that has passed, what was done with the property and the reason for the cancellation. An agreement between the parties does not bind the Tax Authority, even if it has been given the force of a court judgment.

The statutory rule

Section 102 of the Real Estate Taxation Law (Betterment and Purchase), 5723-1963 (the “Law”) provides that the Director of Real Estate Taxation will refund the tax if it is proved to him that a sale of a right in real estate, or a transaction in a real estate association (a company whose assets are mainly Israeli real estate), on which tax was paid has been cancelled. The rule covers the betterment tax paid by the seller and the purchase tax paid by the buyer. The parties notify the Director of the cancellation, and the Director decides whether to recognise it.

The Director’s decision does not depend on whether the cancellation is valid between the parties. A cancellation agreement may be valid under contract law, and may even be given the force of a court judgment, and still not be recognised for tax purposes.

Where the Director refuses to recognise the cancellation, the first sale stands for tax purposes, and the return of the property to the seller is treated as a second sale, in which the original buyer sells and the original seller buys. The betterment tax and purchase tax paid on the first sale are not refunded, and the second sale is taxed in its own right: the original buyer owes betterment tax if the second sale produces a gain, and the original seller owes purchase tax on the property that has come back to him. A single cancelled transaction can therefore lead to betterment tax and purchase tax being paid twice.

The test laid down by the Supreme Court

The leading decision is Civil Appeal 307/85 Director of Betterment Tax, Tel Aviv v. Zemer. A flat was given as a gift, the transaction was reported, and the recipient moved in. About six years later the parties notified the tax authorities that the gift had been cancelled and asked for the tax to be refunded. The Supreme Court held that no refund was due. The court said that once a transaction has had consequences in fact and cannot be undone as if it had never happened, the clock cannot be turned back. It gave weight to the recipient’s possession of the flat, to the flat’s registration in her name with the property tax authorities (mas rechush), and to the six years that had passed before the cancellation.

The typical cancellation that is recognised is one agreed shortly after the contract was signed, before anything was done under it. In a 2009 decision of the Haifa appeals committee, Boueirat v. Director of Betterment Tax, Hadera, a sale contract was cancelled eight days after signing, the buyer had not taken possession, and his deposit was returned. The cancellation was recognised. The more time has passed and the more steps have been taken to carry out the sale, the harder it is to have the cancellation recognised. The burden of proof is on the party seeking the refund.

The factors the courts consider

In Civil Appeal 8340/10 M.V. Investments Ltd v. Israel Tax Authority, decided on 30 January 2013, the Supreme Court listed four factors. The first is the period between the contract and the cancellation. The second is whether the sale was completed or steps were taken to carry it out, such as registration, delivery of possession, drawing income from the property or making changes to it. The third is whether the cancellation was agreed between the parties, in which case it is examined with particular care. The fourth is its purpose: a tax saving or some other economic reason. In that case seven to eight years had passed, the cancellation was between related parties, and the buying company had collected rent from tenants and claimed depreciation. The cancellation was not recognised.

In 2019 the Nazareth appeals committee recognised the cancellation of a 1997 sale of land in Afula, about 22 years after the sale. The sellers had been misled about the value of the land, the sale had never been carried out in practice, and the payment made to the buyers in the settlement was classified as reimbursement of expenses.

Decision Time to cancellation Main facts Result
Boueirat, Haifa appeals committee, 13 August 2009 Eight days No possession taken; deposit returned Recognised
Zemer, CA 307/85 About six years Recipient of the gift lived in the flat Not recognised
M.V. Investments, CA 8340/10, 30 January 2013 Seven to eight years Related parties; buyer collected rent and claimed depreciation Not recognised
K.S.M., Jerusalem appeals committee 49693-04-14, 17 September 2018 Sale made in 2003 Cancelled in a settlement given the force of a judgment, with no defence filed and no evidence heard Not recognised
Nazareth appeals committee, 2019, land in Afula About 22 years Sale never carried out; sellers misled about value; payment to buyers was reimbursement of expenses Recognised
Daas, Lod appeals committee 7106-10-25, 14 November 2026 Four and a half years Buyer obtained a building permit and built a house; price to be repaid in instalments over six years Not recognised

A sale that falls through before completion

A buyer who lives abroad may sign a contract before the purchase money reaches Israel, and a transfer held up by the bank’s compliance review can delay payment beyond the dates in the contract. If the sale is then cancelled, the same factors apply. A cancellation made shortly after signing, before possession passed and before the buyer did anything with the property, with the money returned in full, is closest to the case the courts describe as typical for a refund. A cancellation made after the buyer has taken possession, let the property or started building on it is harder to have recognised.

If the cancellation is recognised, the purchase tax paid by the buyer and the betterment tax paid by the seller may be refunded. If it is not, the return of the property is taxed as a second sale.

A settlement approved by the court does not bind the Tax Authority

In the K.S.M. decision the Jerusalem appeals committee held that where a cancellation agreement was given the force of a judgment without a defence being filed, without a hearing and without evidence, the Director may look behind the judgment and decide for himself whether the cancellation is genuine or is in fact a second sale.

On 14 November 2026 the Lod appeals committee decided Daas v. Director of Real Estate Taxation, Netanya. Two brothers had sold rights in a plot in Tayibe in two transactions in 2020, for NIS 300,000 and NIS 150,000. The buyer undertook to pay the betterment tax, paid only part of it, and the Director began collection proceedings against the sellers. In December 2024 the sellers and the buyer cancelled the sales in a settlement that was given the force of a judgment, and wrote into it that the Director was required to recognise the cancellation and refund the tax. The Director refused, and the court dismissed the sellers’ application to hold him in contempt.

The committee held that a judgment giving effect to a settlement allows the parties to enforce it against each other, and no more. A judgment binds only the parties to the proceedings. A dispute with the Tax Authority is decided through the procedure set out in the Law: a report or application, an assessment and an objection. By the time of the cancellation the buyer had obtained a building permit and built a house on the plot, and the price was to be repaid to him in instalments over six years. The committee chairman, joined in his reasoning by one member, held that the sellers had misused the civil proceedings. The appeal was dismissed and the sellers were ordered to pay NIS 30,000 in costs.

The reason for the cancellation

In Civil Appeal 2881/10 Eli Levi v. Director of Betterment Tax, Rehovot, decided on 23 April 2012, the court cited the view that a cancellation is assessed against what the parties knew when they signed. A cancellation caused by facts unknown to them at the time can be genuine. Where the reason to cancel arose only later and the parties changed their minds, treating the sale as retroactively cancelled is seen as a way of obtaining a tax advantage. In Daas one of the sellers testified that he cancelled because the betterment tax demanded of him was twice the value of the plot he sold. The committee held that this motive did not justify recognising the cancellation for tax purposes.

Points to examine before signing a cancellation agreement

  • The time that has passed since the contract, and what has been done with the property since: possession, registration, letting, a building permit or construction.
  • How the price is returned to the buyer: in full at the time of cancellation, or in instalments. In Daas repayment over six years was among the circumstances that led the committee to refuse recognition.
  • Any payment to the buyer beyond the price, and what it reflects. In the Afula decision the payment to the buyers was classified as reimbursement of expenses.
  • The reason for the cancellation, and when the facts behind it came to light. In Daas a betterment tax bill twice the value of the plot was held not to justify recognising the cancellation.
  • A clause requiring the Tax Authority to recognise the cancellation. Such a clause does not bind the Tax Authority, even where the agreement is given the force of a judgment.
  • Evidence for the affidavit and for any appeal: documents showing the return of the price, the state of the property and who held possession, and testimony from the other party to the sale.

Notifying the Director

Notice of the cancellation is given to the regional Real Estate Taxation office handling the file, on an affidavit of cancellation of a sale of real estate (Form 6130). Both the sellers and the buyers sign the form, and the documents supporting the cancellation are attached to it. A decision refusing to recognise the cancellation can be appealed to the appeals committee under the Law, as in Daas.

Further reading

Sources

Real Estate Taxation Law (Betterment and Purchase), 5723-1963, section 102 · CA 307/85 Director of Betterment Tax, Tel Aviv v. Zemer, PD 41(4) 826 · CA 8340/10 M.V. Investments Ltd v. Israel Tax Authority (30 January 2013) · CA 2881/10 Eli Levi v. Director of Betterment Tax, Rehovot (23 April 2012) · Jerusalem appeals committee 49693-04-14 K.S.M. Kiryat Sefer Centers Ltd v. Director of Real Estate Taxation, Jerusalem (17 September 2018) · Boueirat v. Director of Betterment Tax, Hadera, Haifa appeals committee (13 August 2009) · Nazareth appeals committee (Judge Irit Hod), 2019, land in Afula · Lod appeals committee 7106-10-25 Daas v. Director of Real Estate Taxation, Netanya (14 November 2026) · Form 6130 (Hebrew)

General overview only, not legal advice. Case law and Tax Authority practice change from time to time. Updated 20 November 2026.

x
סייען נגישות
הגדלת גופן
הקטנת גופן
גופן קריא
גווני אפור
גווני מונוכרום
איפוס צבעים
הקטנת תצוגה
הגדלת תצוגה
איפוס תצוגה

אתר מונגש

אנו רואים חשיבות עליונה בהנגשת אתר האינטרנט שלנו לאנשים עם מוגבלויות, וכך לאפשר לכלל האוכלוסיה להשתמש באתרנו בקלות ובנוחות. באתר זה בוצעו מגוון פעולות להנגשת האתר, הכוללות בין השאר התקנת רכיב נגישות ייעודי.

סייגי נגישות

למרות מאמצנו להנגיש את כלל הדפים באתר באופן מלא, יתכן ויתגלו חלקים באתר שאינם נגישים. במידה ואינם מסוגלים לגלוש באתר באופן אופטימלי, אנה צרו איתנו קשר

רכיב נגישות

באתר זה הותקן רכיב נגישות מתקדם, מבית all internet - בניית אתרים.רכיב זה מסייע בהנגשת האתר עבור אנשים בעלי מוגבלויות.