Data of special sensitivity: the definition after Amendment 13, the difference from the GDPR, and the exception in the EU AI Act
Amendment 13 replaced the old definition of sensitive “information” with a list of twelve types of data of special sensitivity. In Israel the classification mainly determines the security level, the duty to notify the Authority and the size of fines. In the European Union it determines whether the data may be processed at all.
The definition in the Law
Under Section 3 of the Privacy Protection Law, 5741-1981, as amended by Amendment 13, “data of special sensitivity” is personal data of any of these types:
- Privacy of family life, intimate life and sexual orientation.
- A person’s state of health, including medical information under the Patient’s Rights Law.
- Genetic data.
- A biometric identifier used or intended for identifying a person or verifying their identity by computer.
- A person’s origin.
- Criminal record.
- Political opinions, religious beliefs or worldview.
- A personality assessment made by a professional, or by a tool designed to assess significant personality traits, such as character, intellectual ability and ability to function at work or in studies.
- Location and traffic data generated by a communications provider, and location data capable of revealing data of the other types on the list.
- Salary data and financial activity.
- Data subject to a statutory duty of confidentiality.
- Further types of data that the Minister of Justice may add in a schedule to the Law, concerning data transferred to Israel from a place where special rules apply to it. To date the schedule lists one type: trade union membership, for data transferred to Israel from the European Economic Area.
The list is broad. It includes financial data, employment screening tests and data covered by professional secrecy, so an accounting firm, a recruitment agency or a law firm also holds data of special sensitivity.
What the classification changes in Israel
Israeli law does not prohibit processing data of special sensitivity. As with all data, the basis for processing is consent or authorisation by law. The classification affects the obligations that accompany processing:
- Notice to the Authority: where the number of people whose data of special sensitivity is held in a database exceeds 100,000, the controller notifies the Authority within 30 days, even if the database is not subject to registration.
- Privacy protection officer: a party whose main business includes processing such data on a significant scale must appoint an officer; see Privacy Protection Officer under Amendment 13.
- Security: under the Data Security Regulations, a database containing types of sensitive data is generally at the medium security level at least, and at the high level where it holds data on 100,000 people or more or has more than 100 authorised users.
- Fines: the fines set by Amendment 13 are doubled where data of special sensitivity is involved, for example NIS 100 instead of NIS 50 per person for a personal request without the required notice, NIS 4 instead of NIS 2 per person in the database for failing to appoint a privacy officer, and NIS 8 instead of NIS 4 per person for processing beyond the purpose or without authorisation.
Special categories under the GDPR
Article 9(1) of the GDPR prohibits processing data revealing racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, or trade union membership, genetic data, biometric data for the purpose of identification, health data, and data concerning sex life or sexual orientation. The prohibition applies unless one of the exceptions in Article 9(2) is met, including explicit consent, obligations in employment and social security law, vital interests where the person cannot consent, data manifestly made public by the person, legal claims, substantial public interest, medicine and public health, and research. Data on criminal convictions and offences is governed separately by Article 10. In addition to an Article 9 exception, the processing needs a legal basis under Article 6.
Comparison
| Topic | Israel | GDPR |
|---|---|---|
| Effect of the classification | Enhanced security, notice to the Authority, officer, doubled fines | Prohibition on processing, unless an exception applies |
| Financial and salary data | Included | Not included |
| Trade union membership | Included only for data transferred from the EEA (paragraph 12 and the Second Schedule) | Included |
| Personality assessment | Included | Not a category |
| Criminal record | Included | Governed separately (Article 10) |
| Data confidential by law | Included | Not a category |
A business subject to both laws needs to examine each type of data twice: against the Israeli list, for security and notice purposes, and against the European list, to determine whether it may be processed.
The exception in the EU AI Act
An AI system that classifies people may discriminate by origin, gender or health. Checking for bias sometimes requires processing exactly the sensitive data the GDPR prohibits. Article 10(5) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the EU AI Act) allows providers of high-risk systems to process special categories of personal data to the extent strictly necessary for detecting and correcting bias, subject to cumulative conditions:
- The bias cannot be detected and corrected effectively using other data, including synthetic or anonymised data.
- Technical limitations on re-use apply, and state-of-the-art security and privacy-preserving measures are used, including pseudonymisation.
- Access to the data is controlled and documented, and limited to authorised persons under confidentiality obligations.
- The data is not transmitted to other parties.
- The data is deleted once the bias has been corrected or the retention period ends, whichever comes first.
- The records of processing activities include the reasons why the processing was strictly necessary.
The exception supplements the GDPR and does not replace it. An Israeli company developing such a system for the European market also needs a basis under Article 6 of the GDPR, and in Israel the data remains data of special sensitivity, with all the obligations that entails. On the EU AI Act, see The EU AI Act Enters Enforcement.
